First home brew review in quite a long time.
I brewed this berliner weisse back in early November, opting for a pretty straightforward grain bill of half pils and half wheat, an ounce of Tettnanger in the mash and a no-boil approach to minimize hop utilization (and thus hindering of bacteria development). I pitched lactobacillus delbrueckii up front, waited a day and pitched the brewer’s yeast. Primary went just fine, secondary was good, and I dosed with another shot of lactobacillus when I bottled several weeks later. Here’s the original recipe for anyone interested.
So how’d my first attempt at a sour turn out?
Poured a very pale straw coloring, like weak lemonade. Copious carbonation and loads of spritz, like a champagne. Aroma is boldly lactic and sour, very nice and promising. Taste is immediately sour, but mildly so. Not as puckering as I would have hoped, which I attribute to lack of sugar in primary for the lactobacillus to consume (pitching the lacto 24 hours ahead of the yeast may not have been enough time, but I was concerned with pH levels). Soft wheat flavoring that leads to a smooth finish. The 2.5% ABV is obviously not a factor here. Mouthfeel is medium, with the sour and carb providing a nice prickly sensation.
Overall, not bad for my first attempt at the style (I know I did something right, because my wife who despises sour ales hates it), but not what I’d call a home run. Definitely very refreshing and I can see myself drinking lots of this on the patio this summer. I may experiment with a sour mash next time I brew this.
Rating: B

January 27, 2010 at 3:00 am
That sounds, and looks, pretty good!
January 27, 2010 at 11:22 am
Well done and thanks for the update. I brewed one up in about the same time frame (early November) with a culture from some greek yogurt and let it run for a week before pitching the yeast. I will probably be kegging it up shortly, and putting on draft in early March.
Did you carbonate to 3.5 vols? If so any issues with pouring at the elevated carbonation levels?
January 27, 2010 at 12:47 pm
How does this compare to Bell’s Oarsman? I really enjoy their new Berliner Weisse, but I like the idea of your ‘no boil’ method.
January 27, 2010 at 1:32 pm
Brian – I carbed to about 2.5 vols, which is my usual 5 oz of priming sugar added to the 5 gallon batch before bottling. I could have upped it to get a higher carb, but based on the results I got I don’t think it was necessary.
FD – I’ve never tried that beer. Best thing I could compare this to is DFH Festina Peche, not super sour but you know it’s there. I was hoping for something like The Bruery’s Hottenroth, but that’s like painting a picture and hoping it turns out like a Picasso. I think I may take an approach more like Brian with his yogurt culture next time, and let the lacto work on the wort longer before I pitch the yeast.
March 12, 2010 at 12:01 pm
You review your own homebrew? Lame, dude, really really really frickin lame.
March 12, 2010 at 1:13 pm
Yes, like any homebrewer, I critique and analyze my own beer. It’s part of the process.
March 24, 2010 at 11:19 am
Any good homebrewer does, but not in an online review. Uber lame. Don’t break your arm patting yourself on the back.
March 24, 2010 at 11:23 am
Thanks for the review and for the honest critique. Knowing how your process and recipe affected the final product is valuable for anyone who wants to brew this fairly rare style.
March 24, 2010 at 4:20 pm
RS (or, should I say, Steve) – thanks for the unsolicited negative commentary about my blog and how I choose to use this site to log my homebrew recipes, results, and learnings. Would have thought someone of your stature locally could appreciate something like that instead of tearing it down.
April 20, 2010 at 2:55 pm
I’m a homebrewer and enjoy reading about other brewer’s experiences. I’m not sure why someone in the home brewing community would make negative comments about another brewer. If you don’t have a good review of how a recipe and the techniques turn out, then there is no way for others to use the information and improve on their own brewing techniques and recipes. I hope rs doesn’t break his arm by patting himself on the back. If you think you’re better than the rest of us then don’t bother reading or replying to blogs that are “uber lame”. Who says that anyway? Grow up.
Thanks for the enjoyable blog