Downtown St. Paul is a quaint little area, a mix of the historic and new. Modern business towers mingle with 1930′s gangster-era theaters. Cobblestone streets lead to corporate coffee shops dotting several street corners. And the tattered remnants of Lowertown warehouses from yesteryear overlook sparkling condominiums on the Mississippi riverfront.
If you’re not careful, you might actually fool yourself into thinking you’re in a thriving city filled with adventure and things to do. But when 5:01 p.m. hits on any given weekday, that thought quickly evaporates as the place becomes a virtual ghost town. Throngs of white starched shirts and pressed business suits filter out of corporate monoliths to make their way to the burbs. Homeless people roll through Rice Park like tumbleweed. And bartenders at watering holes quietly work their way through the day’s Pioneer Press crossword puzzle, waiting for someone…anyone…to give them something to do.
The scene at Great Waters Brewery on St. Peter Street was thankfully a little more lively than that when I showed up Wednesday evening, but not by much. It’s been a while since I’ve been there, and was glad to see a slew of interesting beers on draught. I sampled a few, all of which were mighty tasty:
Cask Rye Pale Ale Dry Hopped with Chinook
Of the eight or 10 beers on tap, about half were cask-conditioned, which I think is great not only for the beer geeks interested in supporting real ale, but also a fun way for your everyday beer drinker to learn more about the difference in unfiltered and unpasteurized ale pushed naturally from the cask. Their Rye Pale Ale dry hopped with Chinook was a great example, poured surprisingly clear with a nice medium amber hue and beautiful combo of the bready rye and pungent aromatic hops in the nose. Taste was not as malty as I expected, but rather a bit dry leading to a spicy finish thanks to the rye. A very enjoyable beer.
Rating: A-
KaizerWeizen Hefeweizen
Poured golden cloudy with yeast like a good hefe should. Really no head to speak of, but that’s likely more a function that it was served in one of their half-pint glasses. Faint banana and bubble gum aroma, leading to a fairly non-descript flavor of light grain. Fairly spritzy mouthfeel. While this was a very clean, obviously well-constructed beer, it only reinforced my general disdain for hefeweizens as a relatively mundane style (unless you’re talking about Weihenstephaner, in which case pour me another!).
Rating: B
Cask Oak-Aged Black Watch Oatmeal Stout
Another cask-conditioned ale in the form of an oatmeal stout. Very deep brown pour, with a really subtle oakiness in the aroma. And in fact, too subtle in my opinion. The bartender told me they age it in oak casks for about a month, which to me doesn’t sound like enough to really impart that unique barrel characteristic. Some nice chocolate and roasted notes in the nose as well. Taste was smooth, almost velvety from the oatmeal. But compared to other stouts, I’d say a bit light in the mouthfeel department. A solid beer overall.
Rating: B

August 13, 2009 at 12:51 pm
I make it here about once a year.
August 14, 2009 at 4:44 am
[...] the Strib and Mecca talk zombies (or zombie bars, anyway), and the Captain’s Chair does a Great Waters brewpub beer roundup. var addthis_pub = "heavytable"; var addthis_options = 'favorites, digg, delicious, stumbleupon, [...]
August 14, 2009 at 9:46 am
Great Waters is a great place, as long as the Wild aren’t playing that night. The headbrewer is super cool, the food is good (especially for a midwestern brewpub), and they have real ale. They have emphasized cask conditioned beer for years, and people are finally catching up around the TC area.
As you note, their location is a blessing and a curse. Still, everything they brew is at the very least well made and interesting, and some of their stuff is among the best in the cities. This is one of those places, along with the Muddy Pig, that makes me think I should get over to St. Paul more often (if not just outright move there). Plus, Meritage is less than a block away…so you can go out for a pleasant evening meal and just slide on through Great Waters for a couple pints.
August 14, 2009 at 9:51 am
I thought it was very cool half their stuff was cask conditioned. They had a pale ale in both regular and cask version, which my friend tried and was able to quickly see the differences.
August 14, 2009 at 10:00 am
Yea, I really enjoy being able to try a beer both ways. I was at Grumpy’s recently when they had a firkin of Bitter Brewer along with the draft version. It’s a totally different experience. One of my favorite local casks is Town Hall’s Masala Mama, and Surly’s Mild on cask is amazing. I seriously believe this is the new trend in beer. So many local bars have bought beer engines and are having such a great response they’ll continue to expand those offerings.
I don’t think all beers are improved by being cask, but it’s always cool to try them.
August 14, 2009 at 10:11 am
I think that’s one of the great things about going to the various festivals throughout the year too (ABR, FirkinFest, etc). It’s kind of like going to a concert, and hearing your favorite band improvise and add new twists to your favorite song off the studio recording…I think for their own sanity, some brewers welcome the opportunity to develop some of these really interesting cask versions based on their traditional stable, whether it’s a straight-up cask edition of their normal offering like Masala Mama, or something like Lift Bridge’s Kimono Girl on cask, which I think is a fantastic beer.
August 14, 2009 at 11:06 am
You forgot to mention it is home to one of the best breakfast ideas in the City, “Pegs, Kegs, and Eggs.” For a low price (I forget it now) you get a pint, some eggs, and are given a cribbage board to use for some games. A truely midwestern morning out if you ask me.
August 14, 2009 at 11:10 am
Great point Amber…I did see the sign for that when I was there. Seemed like a fun idea.
August 14, 2009 at 11:20 am
totally, I love Midwesterncentric cardgames. I am dying to find a group of people in the cities that either wants to learn or knows how to play Sheeps head.
August 17, 2009 at 9:50 am
I was just talking to the Bearded Brewer last night and we agreed this is a great little brewpub but we rarely get there. I’d love to head over and try their cask beers sometime. Sherlock’s Home always had some great real ales on tap (in fact i think that’s all they had on tap). Boy do I miss that place.
August 26, 2009 at 7:21 pm
[...] as some versions of the style really give you a pumpernickel bread kind of flavoring (thinking of Great Water’s Rye Pale Ale I recently had on cask). What you do get is more of a smooth, malty sweetness (maybe some light toffee?) that leads to a [...]